Darabi, Rozhin; Karimi‑Maleh, Hassan; Altuner, Elif Esra; Gulbagca, Fulya; Tiri, Rima Nour Elhouda; Chinnathambi, Arunachalam; Brindhadevi, Kathirvel; Halvaci, Ebru; Sen, Fatih

Editors-in-Chief have retracted this article due to a compromised initial peer review process. A subsequent post-publication review revealed the following concerns: Misuse of the Eyring equation and incorrect interpretation of UV-vis spectroscopy data; A 50% discrepancy between the particle size determined by XRD and TEM that is not addressed in the paper; Multiple issues with Table 1, e.g., the values in the table do not seem to pertain to the same reaction, making comparison confusing; the table also equates “performance” with “activation energy.” Dubious reliability of certain citations. The Editors-in-Chief have therefore lost confidence in the results reported by this article. Fatih Sen, Hassan Karimi-Maleh, Rima Nour Elhouda Tiri, Fulya Gulbagca and Elif Esra Altuner disagree with this retraction. None of the remaining authors have responded to the correspondence from the Publisher about this retraction.

AtıfOpenAlex1

İncele